Differences and Similarities Between PLA and PLA-CF
Getting the desired results from 3D printing relies on using the correct filament. Because of its low price and relative simplicity, Polylactic Acid (PLA) has quickly become one of the most widely used filaments. On the other hand, PLA-CF, short for PLA Carbon Fibre, is making waves due to its exceptional qualities. In case you're trying to decide between PLA and PLA-CF, this article will walk you through the key differences so you can make an informed decision.
What Is PLA?
Corn starch and sugarcane are renewable resources that go into making PLA, a thermoplastic that degrades naturally. Its low melting point, ease of printing, and lack of need for a heated bed make it a popular choice for 3D printing. PLA prints easily and is great for both new and seasoned printer owners. It isn't the strongest material for high-stress applications, but it offers good overall strength.
What Is PLA-CF?
Composite filaments like PLA-CF combine the best qualities of both the original PLA and carbon fiber. Many people like the material's matte finish, increased strength, and stiffness because of the carbon fiber in the filament. The advantages of PLA-CF over regular PLA are not without their drawbacks, especially when it comes to printing and the tools needed for the job.
PLA vs. PLA-CF: A Comparison
1. Differences in Appearance and Surface Finish
The look and appearance are where PLA and PLA-CF differ significantly from one another. The surface of PLA is usually glossy and smooth.
The matte surface of PLA-CF, on the other hand, is appealing to many users because it makes it easier to conceal layer lines, resulting in prints that appear more polished.
Consider PLA-CF if you value aesthetics, particularly when making functional parts or models that require an air of professionalism.
2. Sturdiness and Longevity
PLA has great strength but tends to break easily. Things like prototypes and ornaments that won't be put through their paces are good candidates for this method.
In contrast, the carbon fiber content of PLA-CF makes it more rigid and long-lasting. Because of this, it is perfect for components that require more rigidity and strength. On the other hand, the strength of PLA-CF is a matter of some contention among 3D printers. While PLA-CF does have a higher degree of rigidity, some users have noted that it is also more brittle and can break under specific circumstances, especially at the layer lines.
In a discussion, one user made the observation that PLA-CF "hides layer lines" and prints "more accurately." Although it improves layer adhesion when applied properly, another user cautioned that the majority of carbon fiber filaments contain only carbon dust, which does little to increase strength.
3. Nozzle Requirements
The fact that PLA-CF is abrasive should be considered before using it. The filament's carbon fiber can rapidly wear down a regular brass nozzle. To deal with abrasive materials, you'll require a nozzle made of hardened steel or one of similar construction.
The fact that regular PLA prints smoothly with standard nozzles makes it the preferred choice of most users. If you'd rather not buy a new nozzle or replace your old one too often, regular PLA could be a better choice.
4. Layer Adhesion
Layer adhesion is typically better with regular PLA than with PLA-CF. Under some conditions, the PLA-CF carbon fibers might reduce the material's bonding capabilities, resulting in less robust prints. While PLA-CF has the potential to show excellent layer adhesion when printed correctly, doing so may necessitate more time spent tweaking the print parameters.
Conversely, when it comes to layer bonding, regular PLA is more consistent.
5. Price and Accessibility
PLA is a popular filament among both amateurs and professionals due to its low price. In contrast, PLA-CF is more costly than PLA because of the carbon fiber content and the extra printing requirements. The total cost of purchasing even a small quantity of PLA-CF rolls can be surprising, as one user put it humorously. Be mindful of the additional expense if you are trying to stick to a strict budget.
6. Weight
The addition of carbon fibers makes PLA-CF lighter than ordinary PLA. Drone components and other lightweight structures can benefit from this weight reduction because of the importance of minimizing mass in these applications. The carbon fibers make the filament stronger while simultaneously making it less dense.
7. Print Accuracy
PLA
-Layer Height Accuracy: The high layer height accuracy of PLA makes it a popular filament for printing intricate designs with pinpoint accuracy. Depending on the printer's capabilities, PLA can achieve fine layer heights ranging from 0.05 mm to 0.3 mm. The material adheres well to the print bed and flows smoothly, so the printed dimensions are true to the design file.
-Dimensional Accuracy: PLA typically keeps dimensional accuracy within ±0.1 mm, guaranteeing that printed components will have minimal size variation. This comes in handy for projects that require exact fitting components or attention to detail.
Parts made of PLA don't tend to warp too much as they cool, so they keep their original shapes. Because there is little to no warping, fewer post-processing steps and design adjustments are required to guarantee accurate parts.
PLA-CF
-Accuracy of Layer Height: PLA-CF can also attain fine layer heights, although the carbon fibers embedded within make it slightly less consistent than pure PLA. The added complexity of PLA-CF makes fine-tuning necessary to maintain precision, though typical layer heights for PLA-CF prints are 0.1 mm to 0.3 mm.
-Dimensional Accuracy: When compared to regular PLA, the dimensional accuracy of PLA-CF is marginally lower at approximately ±0.2 mm. The reduced consistency of extrusion is a result of the stiffer carbon fiber content. Prints still come out fairly accurately, though, and that's especially true for functional parts that need to be sturdy and unbending.
The carbon fibers in PLA-CF can have a small impact on accuracy by making the print flow less smoothly, but the matte surface finish can hide these imperfections, making the prints appear more accurate than they actually are.
8. Shrinkage
PLA
With a shrinkage rate usually between 0.3% - 0.7%, PLA is well-known for having low shrinkage during printing and cooling. This makes it a dependable filament for parts that must retain their size and form, lowering the need for intricate design corrections or post-processing. This low shrinkage helps consumers print dimensional components and reduces the possibility of parts being too small or misaligned.
The low shrinkage rate of PLA guarantees that models maintain their intended proportions and details, especially for larger parts printing. PLA is often chosen for highly detailed or large-scale prints since there is less concern regarding warping or contracting during the cooling process.
PLA-CF
With an average shrinkage between 0.8% and 1.2%, PLA-CF has a rather higher shrinkage rate than standard PLA. Though they somewhat increase shrinkage compared to conventional PLA, the carbon fibers in the material lower the total shrinkage when compared to other fiber-filled filaments like ABS-CF. Particularly in larger parts, this can cause dimensional variations throughout the cooling process.
Using PLA-CF could allow one to compensate for shrinkage in parts needing great dimensional accuracy. While careful calibration and slicer adjustments can help lower the impact, users may find it necessary to oversize their designs somewhat to allow for shrinkage.
When to Choose PLA?
If this is your first time 3D printing or if the items you're making don't require anything particularly sturdy, PLA is an excellent material to use. Additionally, it works wonderfully for ornamental items, models, and prototypes. Printing with PLA is simple, doesn't call for any specialized tools, and it's cheap and readily available. Plastic is the best option if you want a flexible filament that's easy to work with.
Why Should You Opt for PLA-CF?
If your print needs more rigidity and strength, PLA-CF is the way to go. It's an excellent material for functional components, particularly those that are prone to wear or require structural integrity when subjected to stress. It does, however, necessitate a hardened nozzle due to its abrasive nature. The flat, matte surface of PLA-CF lends an air of professionalism to printed components meant for public display.
Best 3D Printing Software
There are many 3D printing software available that can prepare designs for 3D printing and a good example is SelfCAD. It is an easy-to-use 3D design software that you can use not only to create 3D models but also to edit meshes and slice designs. It comes with interesting 3D modeling tools like freehand drawing and sketching that you can use to create designs from scratch.
There are also easy to use selection modes as well as various modification tools to help you modify your designs based on your requirements. It also has an image-to-3D feature that makes it easier to turn photos to 3D models. You can also import STL files and modify them based on your needs. For example, you can import an STL file and color it, as shown below.
The software features a built-in online slicer that one can use to prepare designs for 3D printing. The video below shows how to slice STL files and generate the Gcode to send to the 3D printer.
Choosing the Right Filament
The final decision between PLA and PLA-CF should be based on your individual requirements. The advantages of PLA include its low cost, adaptability, and ease of use. However, PLA-CF is a good option to consider if you want a matte finish and increased strength and are willing to invest in a hardened nozzle. Some users recommend testing a little to determine whether the advantages of PLA-CF exceed the difficulties for your particular projects before committing to a full roll. You can make a well-informed decision by learning about the benefits and drawbacks of both filaments.
Enjoy powerful modeling, rendering, and 3D printing tools without the steep learning curve.
Need to learn 3D modeling? Get started with interactive tutorials.