How to Fix 3D Printer Extruder Clicking Issues
As the printhead moves and filament is extruded onto the build surface, your 3D printer should normally make some noise, such as a buzzing or whirring sound, during the FDM 3D printing process. While running, desktop 3D printers can make as much noise as a reasonably quiet refrigerator—up to 50 dB. But if you hear clicking noises that seem to be breaking up your machine's usual hum, there might be an issue.
There could be some complications with the slicer settings or the calibration of the 3D printer if the extruder starts clicking. The most common reasons for an extruder to make a clicking sound include high temperatures, blocked nozzles, and excessive spring tension. Get the lowdown on fixing this 3D printing problem so you can get more reliable prints every time.
What Causes Extruder Clicking?
If your extruder is clicking, you need to identify the source of the problem before you can solve it. Important to 3D printing, the extruder regulates the flow of filament into the hot end. So as to melt the filament and deposit it onto the build plate or previous layers, the extruder motor powers a gear that grasps the filament and pushes it through the hot end. For continuous filament flow and best printing results, extruder performance is paramount.
If the extruder gears, which press the filament into the hot end, have trouble doing their job, the extruder will typically start skipping or clicking. The stepper motor, which generates the clicking sound, increases its force output to spin the gears, which causes it to skip backward to offset the increased pressure.
There are a few potential culprits for extruder gear difficulties. To help you print more consistently, we'll go over the most typical reasons for extruder clicking and how to fix them all.
1. Low Temperature
Printing at an excessively high temperature can cause filaments to melt too rapidly, leading to problems like oozing and stringing; temperature is thus a crucial factor in 3D printing. The filament won't melt quickly enough if the print temperature is too low, which can cause nozzle clogs. The extruder in the printer will have trouble feeding filament through a clogged nozzle, which might cause skipping.
Thankfully, this issue has a simple solution: simply increase the print temperature incrementally, by approximately 5°C, until the filament begins to flow more freely. Keep in mind that the ideal print temperature for each filament type is different. After printing PLA, you'll need to change the print settings to accommodate ABS or PETG. As an example, the print temperature range for ABS is 220-250°C, whereas the lower limit for PLA is 200-210°C.
2. Low Nozzle Position
The nozzle height might be the culprit if you're still hearing extruder-clicking noises coming from a partially blocked nozzle, even after checking the temperature, because the nozzle squashes the filament if it's too near to the print bed, and the filament won't extrude onto the build surface correctly. The melted filament adheres to the outside of the nozzle, leading to nozzle jams and under-extrusion in your prints.
The easiest solution to the problem of filament accumulation outside the nozzle and a clicking extruder is to level the bed of your 3D printer. If you're using a manual 3D printer and don't have an automatic bed leveler, a regular piece of paper is a good substitute. Position the nozzle in the corner of the build plate and set a sheet of paper underneath. Bring the nozzle down until it is just touching the paper; the paper will not slip out, but it can still move around. Make sure to do this in every corner of the work surface.
3. Nozzle Blockage
You can hear clicking from the extruder if your 3D printer has gotten stuck for whatever reason. In such a case, unclogging the nozzle is just the beginning; you'll also need to determine where the obstruction is coming from, which may require modifying the print speed or retraction settings, or even changing the temperature. To fix a partial blockage, where some filament is still passing through, you can either use cleaning filament to clear the blockage or a wire brush to remove the accumulation of filament from the nozzle's surface.
It is possible to clear a completely clogged nozzle using one of several methods:
- To separate the filament from the heated nozzle, you can use a fine needle or wire that is smaller than the nozzle's diameter. You may clear the block and let the trash flow out by doing this.
- A 3D printer nozzle can be unclogged using the cold pull technique, which is also rather common. First, load a length of filament into the print head of your 3D printer. Then, heat the extruder to a temperature of 200 to 250°C, depending on the filament. Then, you can do the cold pull. After the filament has been set, you must allow the print head to cool. Then, quickly remove the filament from the extruder after the 3D printer has reheated to a lower temperature (115°C). The filament ought to have separated from the accumulation after bonding with it.
4. Extruder Spring Tension
One or two gears assist the extruder in FDM 3D printing to push filament into the material. Although a stepper motor drives the gears' motion, the extruder also uses tension to hold the filament firmly in place as it feeds it into the printer at a consistent rate. The extruder spring is responsible for producing this strain.
Too much tension in the extruder spring causes the gear teeth to press down on the filament, distorting it. In addition to slowing the filament's feed rate, high tension can make the stepper motor work harder or possibly skip. If you hear clicking from your extruder, it's because of the skipping motor.
It will be necessary to apply more force to feed the filament into the printhead if the spring tension is too low since the extruder gears cannot adequately grasp the filament. Deterioration of the filament and grinding noises are two issues that can result from the increased friction.
Therefore, if you want your prints to turn out perfectly, you need to adjust the tension on your extruder spring. A screw or knob is usually available on 3D printers to change the spring tension. If the clicking continues after you've completely relaxed the tension, try releasing it and then slowly tightening it again.
5. Idler Wheel Too Tight
This method of troubleshooting is suitable for extruders with a single gear. A circular bearing called an idler wheel, or roller guides the filament into the printhead along the one gear. Similar to excessive spring tension, excessively tightening the idler wheel causes the gear to begin crushing the filament, which in turn causes extrusion problems and stepper motor skipping.
As you thread the thermoplastic filament through your extruder, you can see if the idler wheel is accurate. If you can see tiny marks on the filament from gear teeth, it means the gears are grabbing onto it tightly enough to move it quickly. Adjust the idler wheel tension to release any compressed or distorted filament. There will be less chance of clicking and failed prints if you do this.
6. Faulty Extruder Motor
If the extruder is clicking, it can be because of the stepper motor. Inconsistent filament feeding and, by extension, clicking can occur if the stepper motor is either miscalibrated or not linked to a stable power source. Try modifying your settings before making significant hardware modifications; this problem is less common than the ones discussed before.
Check the wiring to ensure everything is firmly in place if you suspect a defective stepper motor is the cause of the clicking extruder. The stepper motor can sometimes become malfunctioning due to something as simple as a loose wire or connection. After that, you can look for suggested motor settings in your 3D printer's firmware. You can usually find reference motor current figures online, which will show you how the motor should be running.
7. Faulty Hotend
3D printing's "hotend" is where all the action takes place. Extrusion of the filament from the nozzle occurs when it has been heated to the correct temperature and melted into a semi-liquid state. Any problem with the hotend might lead to extrusion problems or even clicking noises, so the process must run smoothly to guarantee a constant and uninterrupted flow of filament. Clogs, jams, and stringing are just a few problems that can arise from defective hotend parts.
Checking the heater cartridge and thermistor connections is the first step in diagnosing a broken hotend. A new heater cartridge might be needed if the old one shows signs of failure. Regarding the thermistor, the same is true. Also, make sure the hotend is clear of any obstacles and that the cooling fan is running smoothly. It could be worth upgrading to a higher-quality or all-metal hotend in some instances to get better performance.
8. Filament Quality
Extrusion quality is another factor to consider while using 3D printer filament. Problems with the extruder can arise from low-quality filament due to its inconsistent diameter. The extruder will make a clicking noise if the filament is too thick since it will have trouble feeding it through the hotend. On the flip side, the extruder gears won't be able to grasp the filament adequately if it's too thin, which will result in the stepper motor skipping.
It is worth it to spend money on high-quality filament from trusted manufacturers to guarantee that the extruder won't click due to filament quality. Make sure to search for filaments that have consistent roundness and strict diameter tolerances, usually ±0.02 mm. Furthermore, avoid extrusion problems caused by moisture absorption by storing your filament correctly.
Having looked at how to fix 3D printer extruding, it’s also important to have a look at the best 3D printing software that you can use to create your 3D models and even prepare them for 3D printing. There are many that are available, but we recommend using SelfCAD. It is an easy to use 3D design software that comes with all the necessary tools that you need to create your files from scratch or edit the ones designed in other programs.
In addition to 3D modeling tools, the software also comes with 3D printing tools like the magic fix that you can use to fix any non-manifold issues in 3D prints. There is also an in-built online slicer that you can use to slice your files and generate the G-code to send to your 3D printer.
Eliminate Clicking and Optimize Your Prints
Several factors in your 3D printing system, such as temperature, nozzle obstructions, filament quality, and extruder calibration, might contribute to a clicking extruder. You can make sure your 3D printing goes off without a hitch by methodically finding and fixing these possible issues. The easiest way to avoid extrusion problems and get the highest print quality is to do regular maintenance, use high-quality components, and calibrate correctly. If you have already done all of the methods listed above and the clicking is still happening, you may want to contact the manufacturer of your 3D printer or look for help online.
Enjoy powerful modeling, rendering, and 3D printing tools without the steep learning curve.
Need to learn 3D modeling? Get started with interactive tutorials.